British Banking Nationalisation?

RIP or get well soon? Let me give you a personal perspective.At the age of 26 in 2001, I arrived in the Czech Republic for a two year secondment with Deloitte. On my first day there, an American boss pulled me into his office to tell me the lay of the land. Amongst other things, he informed me that, in his opinion, the Czech government’s woeful/criminal (?) management of the banking sector had cost every taxpayer the equivalent of a year’s salary.

During the 1990s the Czech government had ‘liberalised’ the banking sector without actually privatising it, therein blocking necessary modernisation of the bloated banks and resulting in (ahem) leniency for politically favoured customers. Naturally, this situation eventually led to a pretty nasty banking/currency crisis in 97/8 followed by several “Austerity” budgets.

Fortunately, the Czech Republic did take firm action to restore confidence in the banking sector – ringfencing distressed assets and selling off the large state-owned banks to reputable foreign banks. On a personal level, it was a great opportunity for me as I worked closely with some of these banks attempting to change the organisational culture and develop the skill set to compete in the free market. At the micro level, here are some of the measures the newly private banks took to improve their efficiency.

– Zero-based budgets (i.e. budgets that are based on what needs to be done rather than what was spent last year)
– Staff training on credit management to improve credit decisions, credit valuation and Workout effectiveness.
– Removed time-servers/blockers
– Encouraged entrepreneurial thinking and customer focus
– Changed back office functions from cost centres to profit centres.
– Improved financial reporting
– Enhanced management information (e.g. KPI suites etc)

Look at the Czech Republic’s economic growth data series

1997 0.3%
1998 -2.3%
1999 0.5%
2000 3.6%
2001 2.5%
2002 1.9%
2003 3.6%
2004 4.5%
2005 6.4%
2006 6.4%
2007 6.5%

One of the main lessons I learnt from my first work experience in Czech was that a properly functioning capital market/banking sector is a pre-requisite for a strong economy – almost more important than anything else. This is why when our government takes major stakes in the four major UK banks (apart from the worrying implications/unintended consequences for the rest of the UK banking sector), immediately I want to hear about the states’ exit/re-privatisation strategy. I haven’t heard a thing. People may like to read and learn from this report. If there is an appetite to get the UK back on its feet it may become very relevant in the nearish future.


5 thoughts on “British Banking Nationalisation?

  1. I don’t think the Government want to keep them in public hands for longer than is required either and I’m sure they have an exit strategy. But it isn’t just in the UK where this is happening. Not long after Northern Rock, the US Government effectively privitised Freddie Mac and Fannie May, two huge mortgage institutions. They’ve carried out a similar scheme in the UK and I know other contries are doing that too.

    At least with public banks you know your money is safer.

  2. “I’m sure they have an exit strategy”

    I doubt it.

    Where do you get your faith in the bunch of third-rate trade unionists, teachers and lawyers running the country?

    “At least with public banks you know your money is safer.”

    In the very short-term, possibly.

  3. Wait for it…. I agree with the governments action in nationalising the banks!… but dom is right… this HAS to be a short term strategy. Brown needs to detail his get out plan.

  4. Prague, I doubt anyone would do something this huge without having a plan in place for exiting. It is how good this strategy is that will decide whether the Government has made a hash of it or it has been a success.

    It is not just about exiting by selling the shares, it is also about making sure practices are in place to allow the banking sector to get back to close to how it was but ensure proper regulation is in place to stop it happening again.

    We need a firm worldwide stabilisation plan before we exit.

    Still, it is driving fuel prices down so the big black cloud does have a silver lining.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s