Hodge is right about the Proms but not much else..



Margaret Hodge said this:

“Just as culture pushes boundaries it can make some people feel proud to belong, it can make others feel isolated and deeply offended.”

This is half right, half wrong.

Culture does push boundaries. The definition of culture is such: “the development of the mind.” Culture can also make people proud to belong. If I acquire a particular interest in early renaissance art, I am bound to meet others who share my interest, and it is one that we are likely to be proud of.

I disagree with Hodge on this point though: That culture can make others feel isolated and offended. This is wrong. Pure cultural expression doesn’t make anyone feel isolated. People usually get over the fact that they may not share the common interest of another group. An unfamiliar culture might make people feel interested or ambivalent, challenged or unchallenged, but not isolated.

Hodge moves on to praise ‘icons of common culture’ like Coronation Street over divisive forms such as Jerry Springer the Opera. But the opera proves my point, not Hodge’s. It was an interpretation that some found challenging, entertaining and even right or wrong. But no one felt isolated. True, it didn’t bind a great part of society together like Coronation Street does, but it didn’t isolate either, and it certainly shouldn’t offend anyone, no more than the gutter morality of Eastenders should.

Hodge also refers to the last night of the Proms as an isolationist, offensive cultural form. However, unlike with her first example, she’d be right. The last night of the Proms is a politically conceived night of pomp, flag waving and fat ladies singing. It is this manipulation that makes the last night of the Proms isolationist and offensive, which organic and untouched culture is not.

Hodge’s use of the example also has a wonderful irony. Her demand for a common cultural identity is precisely the same demand that resulted in the last night of the proms. In the case of the last night, centuries of classical music is purposefully bent towards British patriotism or even Jingoism. Oh, and it does nothing for classical music.

Common cultural identity is arguably a good thing, but the determined manipulation of cultural expression contaminates culture. The same contamination saw Edward Elgar demoted from the pantheon of great composers on to the back of a twenty pound note. It takes away from the richness of culture and its capacity to expand minds. For Margaret Hodge to suggest otherwise is cretinous, dangerous even, but probably not surprising.


2 thoughts on “Hodge is right about the Proms but not much else..

  1. Daniel, as always a very well thought out argument of which you are half right, half wrong.

    what you say about organic culture is spot on, i am impressed actually. however feel you have over thought the last night of the proms concert. it has become now just the traditional ed of the roms seris where we all wave a few flags, jig up and down to the hornpipe and pass a ridiculously long hanky round for the faux depressing cello solo. i agree that if it had the same political connotations of the past then it would isolationist, but people not longer think we rule the waves, be them foriegn or native, it is just nostalgic now,

    it is not isolationist but an evening of traditional fun, the proms concerts itself are hughly diverse and incorporate and this is jus tthe knees up at the end, the staff aprty of culture.

    at no other concert do i get to put stupid paper streamers on my bow, i do not want to loose this. for one night of the year we are abit jingoistic, well ok get over it. and if u feel isolated get over it too, as this is one of the most diverse countries for expressing your own cultural idenity.

    this is an argument based more on my nostalgia i understand, and probally doesn’t have the logance of you daniel, but i think i am right. hehe.

    oh and dan, i think u had a few strokes before on here.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s